Nutrition insight: Mass gain experiment with Chris Chapman
We have another article from our resident nutritionist Chris Chapman, aka MisterC aka M&Ms (who is now also making regular appearances in a monthly Mens fitness publication!)
This one provides some insight into his experiences in gaining weight. Yes, that's right, GAINING weight! Enjoy.
Introduction
This article combines my knowledge of nutrition, with my experiences as a Crossfitter, so hopefully many of you will find it relevant. In my 16 years of training, I’ve always been a “hard gainer.” To put it simply no matter how I trained, what I ate, and how much I wanted to put on some muscle, I always had the – enviable to some, no doubt – ability to maintain a pretty constant body weight.
For a while I’d been hearing about programmes which promised large gains in lean mass over a relatively short period, provided you put the hours in at the gym and were willing to consume a lot of calories – programmes like these are pretty well known to most, the best known being Squats and milk and Gallon of Milk a Day (GOMAD).
Theoretical background
The underlying mechanism for this process is the energy balance. This basically states that if you take in more energy through food than you expend, the body will store this energy. Usually this takes place in the form of fat, but under the right stimulus, i.e. strength training, and given enough protein, the body will store this protein as muscle.
The use of milk as excess calories here is simply due to its relative ease to consume. Drinking a gallon of milk will give you an extra 2400kCal, 200g carbs, 120g fat, 120g protein on top of your regular daily diet. Obviously, eating enough solid food to give you all these extra nutrients would be a quite a challenge, so milk is the way to go to tip the energy balance over to storage. While the milk is high in carbohydrates, which produce an insulin spike, this has a positive effect in this case because the insulin causes protein to be sequestered into muscle cells. Also, and quite importantly here, full fat milk is a good source of saturated fat. While the merits of this as a nutrient are the subject of much debate, in this case it has its benefits because this fat serves as a precursor to testosterone, which is needed for heavy weight training and muscle growth.
What I did
The Nutrition
Being a Crossfitter, I like rather more variety in my training than the Squats and Milk programme offered, so I thought I’d have a stab at GOMAD. In the literature about it, it says that drinking 4 litres (or 8 pints!) of full fat milk a day is not easy (true), so it’s a good idea to ramp up the amount as you go along. I planned to start on half a gallon, and increase it over the first week or 2 until I was on the full gallon. I never got to the full gallon stage; the most I regularly consumed was 6 pints a day. Below is an example of what I ate each day when I was consuming the greatest amount of milk:
· Breakfast (also post-workout, as I train first thing): smoothie – pint of whole milk, tablespoon of peanut butter, 1-2 bananas, 1 & ½ scoops of whey protein powder;
· AM: apple, 3 mini Babybel, large handful of almonds, pint of whole milk;
· Lunch: chicken breast, vegetable sticks and cherry tomatoes, small pot of hummus, pint of whole milk
· PM: large handful of almonds, pint of whole milk
· Dinner: wholewheat pasta, 3 sausages, tomato and vegetable sauce, pint of whole milk
· Eve: whatever I wanted, usually chocolate with nuts, but anything to get in as many calories as possible – peanut M&Ms came in useful here, as a 250g bag has over 1,000 calories – plus a pint of whole milk;
· Daily supplements: fish oil, multi-vitamin and –mineral, probiotic.
This lot comes to a total of 5,330 kCalories, 450g carbohydrate, 284g protein, 272g fat.
The Training
As for training, I adapted my usual metcon-aholic training, to a programme that offered more heavy lifting. I liked the look of the Crossfit Strength Bias, not only because it offered more heavy lifting which would provide more muscle-building stimulus, but also because strength training is a weakness in my armoury, and this offered the opportunity to address this at the same time as my mass-building experiment. My training schedule throughout the GOMAD looked like this:
· Day 1: squats, press, sub-5 minute metcon;
· Day 2: longer (20m-ish) metcon using bodyweight exercises and/or running/rowing/skipping;
· Day 3: heavy lift (usually deadlift or power clean), sub-12 minute metcon
· Day 4: rest
· Day 5: as day 3
· Day 6: as day 2
· Day 7: as day 3
· Day 8: Rest
What happened to me
Weight gain certainly happened – my weight steadily increased from 11stone 3lbs to 12stone 8lbs in 3 weeks. Obviously not all of this was muscle, but once I stopped taking in all the extra calories and trimmed down, I stopped at 11 stone 12, a net gain of 9 pounds of muscle. On top of this, during the period my strength numbers went through the roof. Of the 12 different lifts I trained during this period, I got a personal best on 9, and as an illustration, my 1-rep max back squat went from 105kg to 115kg – this was something of a miracle, since I have always struggled with my squat.
However, it wasn’t all easy and pleasant. For the first couple of days, I revelled in being able to eat as much as I wanted. Drinking the milk wasn’t too much of a problem either to begin with. However, within a few days I started to feel full all the time. This persisted for at least a week after I finished the programme, and it took that much time for me to feel hungry again. I also felt bloated and my abdomen looked distended. I also experienced gastrointestinal discomfort.
However, overall the effect was positive. The muscle mass I gained I have kept despite returning to my previous diet, and the bloating and appetite loss soon disappeared. I did this in June, and when the weather turned colder and I had to dig out my winter clothes, I noticed they fitted tighter, especially around the shoulders, thighs and glutes.
Conclusion
Overall, it proved an interesting experiment, and one that showed that these systems are much-vaunted because they do work. If you want to add mass, they will certainly work, although at the time the side-effects were very unpleasant, and are worth bearing in mind if considering this course of action. If I did it again, I might invest in some lactase (the enzyme which helps us digest the sugars in milk) which could help reduce the bloating.
